Why a Healthy Community Is Not a Commodity
by Stephanie Narayanan, Director of Development and External Relations
We’re talking about fundraising all wrong. Not just at PCC, but collectively.
Not because we’re peddling deliberate misinformation, but because we’re upholding antiquated ideas about what donations—and our organizations—actually do.
Many religious traditions—including mine—emphasize regularly giving back to the faith community as an essential part of participation. In fact, being counted as a “congregant” in the annual reporting for an Episcopal parish requires both a certain amount of worship participation and some level of financial support. That says something to me about why we give, in a faith community or anywhere else. Giving where we’re able is a part of full participation. It is acknowledging that our resources reflect more than our own efforts by investing in our shared future.
In contrast, much of the donor stewardship advice talks about centering the donor and what their gift bought. Your gift fed a family. Your gift provided diabetes care for five patients. You, you, you. I understand why that works, and I think it’s a bad idea. Like Vu Le—whose blogging about nonprofits, philanthropy, and "community-centric fundraising" has influenced my thinking—I take issue with key elements of this donor-centric fundraising.
It feels good to focus on the individual action, but it ignores the collective effort that goes into feeding or caring or most anything good. If we tell people about the outcomes stripped of the process, are we not just propping up American individualism? Are we not perpetuating GoFundMe problem solving at the expense of shared and focused effort? If we tell people about the outcomes they “bought” and ignore the organizational effort that goes into achieving them, we keep building this myth of individual charity as the ultimate problem-solver—not well-resourced professionals who translate intention into action.
“We keep building this myth of individual charity as the ultimate problem-solver—not well-resourced professionals who translate intention into action.”
For most direct service organizations, every family fed also means at least a portion of an executive director and volunteer coordinator salaries, as well as the back-office systems that manage inventory and scheduling. And that example assumes an incredibly lean operation that can respond to immediate hunger needs but has no added capacity for upstream work.
At PCC, our focus on system building makes the impact of donor dollars even more nebulous. Our donors are not buying a certain number of healthcare visits—at least not usually. More often, they’re buying the time to design solutions. They’re supporting the unfunded time between identifying a service roadblock and sending a pilot proposal out the door. They are affirming the work we currently do by investing in what’s next.
When we as nonprofit organizations make our year-end asks, I want us to make a more ambitious case. I want us to move away from this model of donor dollars buying a certain amount of good, as though better communities operate on the same pricing model as holiday pajamas. I want us to tell people that they are partners and participants in the long, hard work of a better world. I want us to tell them that individual dollars can buy responses. Real solutions require community investment.